BF Skinnerize your Commitments to Get Through the Rough Patches

by Brad Isaac on August 13, 2009

It’s common for people with big goals to get frustrated, maybe even angry they aren’t going as fast as we’d like them to go. Yesterday, I had an opportunity to discuss this with a friend. He was mad that he didn’t burn enough calories during his workout plan – his goal is to get in shape.

First, I asked “What commitment did you make to yourself?”  He said that he hadn’t really made a commitment except that he wanted to get in shape.

It may seem like an argument of semantics, but I disagree.  He did make a commitment to take action.  But he may not have been entirely conscious of the commitment. It may have been as simple as “I’ll exercise every day for 30 minutes.”  Otherwise, what is there to be angry about?

Let me give an example.  You are meeting a friend for dinner.  She says she’ll be there at 7 o’clock.  7:45 rolls around and she finally arrives.  You are angry – or at least irritated.  Why?  Because she broke the commitment.  If she had said “I’ll be there sometime tonight.”  And she still arrived at 7:30 are you still mad?  No. She didn’t break the commitment.  My friend had a commitment that he felt he broke, but I’m not sure he was aware of what the commitment was.

Clarify Commitments

Conscious or not, I think we should be aware of our commitments and clarify them.  If my friend could put his finger on what he’s expecting from himself and write it out, then it’s easier tracked.  It will all boil down to yes or no questions “Did I exercise 30 minutes today?”

Choose Reasonable Commitments

Commitments should be stuff you can do.  If you’ve never exercised a day in your life, and you are holding yourself to 2 hours a day of 7 days a week, that’s a recipe for failure.  Like the saying goes “inch by inch….”  To be successful, we must commit to that “inch” 3-5 times a week.

On the other hand, one inch every 3 or 4 weeks (depending on how you feel at the time) just isn’t going to cut it.

Rewards and Punishment

I’d also recommend rewarding good behavior and punishing bad.  Say after a day of working out you can enjoy a DVD movie, popcorn and a glass of wine.  Then after a week of working out for the days committed treat yourself to an evening out.  But if you miss a day, then no enjoyable activities that same night.  No DVD, no popcorn, and you sure as hell aren’t getting any wine either. The punishment must be swift and you must stick to it.

Holding your own feet to the fire can be tough, but it’s crucial. Saying “oh just this once I won’t meet my commitment but I’m still going to watch my favorite show” undermines progress.  The next time you don’t feel like doing it, it becomes that much easier to shrug off.  An evening of “adult time-out” might just motivate you to meet your commitment right then and there so you can get it over with and get back to the fun.

If you see a reward at the end of the tunnel ONLY for meeting your commitment and a punishment for not doing it, then doing what you need to becomes second nature.

Arguably this is very BF Skinnerish, but it works.  It’s worked for me on countless occasions.  I had frequent rewards in place.  And I had rewards every week for weekly success.   But I also had punishments for not doing lined up too that I forced myself to stick to.  I still weep thinking of all those nights of Counter-Strike I missed just because I couldn’t get my act together.

No dessert can be just as effective on adults as on our kids…

Set powerful goals online with our new online goal management tool

{ 6 comments }

Jon August 14, 2009 at 1:00 pm

Any post that references Skinner gets my attention. I’ve always used rewards as a motivator, but never punishment for failing to follow through on my goals. I’ll have to give this a try.
.-= Corporate Barbarian´s last blog ..Self-Reliance Series #5C: Prepping Your Home for an Emergency: Communications, Lighting, and Tools =-.

B. Riley August 14, 2009 at 1:16 pm

Very nice! So many times I fall victim to that same thing. I know I want to do something, but I don’t set a specific S.M.A.R.T goal. It’s hard to know when you’re meeting, or breaking a commitment, if you don’t even know what that looks like.

August 15, 2009 at 9:53 pm

Seriously great post!

This was exactly what I needed to hear right now! It’s so true, that all we can do is commit to an action. We can’t commit to results.

You can’t control what will happen, you can only control your actions.
.-= Kaizan´s last blog ..If You’re Not Complaining, There’s Something Wrong With You =-.

August 18, 2009 at 11:54 am

Great advice and good work on the title of your post. Cute!
.-= Nik Halik´s last blog ..Make Your Life A Mosaic of Colorful Experiences =-.

Yonathan Zarkovian August 18, 2009 at 8:48 pm

I’ll try to implement your suggestions: Reward when meeting commitments and punish when not.

September 13, 2009 at 10:51 am

I am speaking from an early childhood teaching point of view. The most important of all forms of reward and punishment is never material in nature. We have asked ourselves so often what can I get for being good and what should I deserve if I do not behave. Day after day, this takes a toll on our own natural way of doing things. To get the rewards, we definitely have to start sing positive praises to ourselves. We spend so much time saying grace and doing good deeds, why not reward ourselves looking in the mirror and say, ‘You’re great!” That to me the best reward a child could ever get for a job well done. Why do we need anything else when we grow up? Like you have indicated, we start to set goals which are unachieveable. If we start enjoying the little achievement and progress, we have actually conquered the distance. Time tells, if we cannot list 3 things we can sing praise to ourselves for something we do well for ourselves, odds are we cannot see ‘the reward’ at the end of week.

If you are interested, this is what I recommend for all to read:
Childhoodspeech Recommends
.-= Annie Cook´s last blog ..7 Reasons Why Language And Religion Are Different =-.

{ 3 trackbacks }

  • Chuck Dennis
  • Corporate Barbarian Links: Sports Physical Edition « The Corporate Barbarian Blog
  • Persistence Unlmtd

Previous post:

Next post: